captainy avatar image

Raw feeders

So why would vets not recommend feeding raw?  

We just dropped Chef off to get nuetered.  He weighed in at 42.6lbs (6 months).  He is solid, but not fat.   We mentioned we started feeing him some raw and the lady at the desk said something like "oh the vet would not recommend that?".  We just started feeding him the  Nature's Variety frozen raw along with some kibble.  He loves it and has been doing well.  At this point we are not planning on going all raw because we live in an apartment, not a large freezer to buy bulk.   But that may change in the future.

We didn't pursue the conversation.   We do not plan to change his diet.  They recommened Science Diet and it did not agree with him at all. So I'm not really onboard with their recommendations anyway.   Just curious on what their reasoning would be.\

Here is his "Why haven't you fed me yet" look?  He was not happy about not getting breakfast this morning.

__________________

Chef D's Mug Shot

Céline and Angel Stella's picture

Aww Chef

No breakfast is the WORST!!  Good luck with your "snip, snip", big guy!

I can't help with the raw question, sorry. 

vet recommended

If he is a Science Diet reccommends (sshheesh no matter how I spell that it looks wrong--the heck with it)  It is very possible he gets kick backs from science diet.  we used to go to a vet that sold it right there at the vet, and it is what he pushed...he got a very nice kick back every quarter.  Not saying it is a horrible food, but it is like a doctor  perscribing a medication, and getting kick backs from the drug companies!  The do have an awesome canned food for cats and for dogs that is called AD, great if you have one that has been horribly sick and needs to gain weight, we nursed a persian back to health with it, and my boston when I rescued it from Parvo.

Anyway, dont know about raw, but I know alot of people swear by it.  Certainly cannot take seriously the threat of samonilla-----its in a huge portion of the kibble, so that is a mute point now!

__________________

Loves and Smooches, Kippa and Mama (Annette)

 

maggie6612's picture

Yup Science diet donates a

Yup Science diet donates a lot of money to vet schools..so the vets are taught to feed science diet. I am not sure why they would recommend that food it really is not good at all. Even if they are not a fan of raw diets they should at least promote a halfway decent kibble! Or take a look at the ingredients that go into science diet such as "corn gluten meal or chicken by-product meal." I cannot take any vet seriously if they tell me to feed my dog that food. Sorry for the rant but it really bothers me!!!  

__________________

captainy's picture

I like them overall

just not on this subject.  It's not like the force it down my throat.  I did research before getting Chef D and knew I would not feed him Science Diet.  Although we started him out with Wellness (swtiched from Nutro Ultra the breeder gave him) and he actually did better with Science Diet (sample bag they gave us ;).  Blue Buffalo Lamb with rice and the raw Nature's Variety seems to be the best for him.

I was just surprised about the comment they would not recommend a raw diet.

__________________

Chef D's Mug Shot

maggie6612's picture

I'm sorry I did not word that

I'm sorry I did not word that right..I do not mean that your vet isn't good! Most vets recommend that food not just yours! But to answer your original question I think that they are taught/believe feeding your dog a raw diet is "dangerous". They say that the dog could get salmonella or swallow/choke on a bone..but in reality there seems to be a good amount of salmonella sitting in all the dog food bags lately. And as for the bones anything is possible but your dog could also choke on chew bones, toys, sticks. etc. 

__________________

Deb and MacKenzie and Ester's picture

Vets and Raw Feeding

There are actually alot of vets that highly recommend a raw diet...but they are certainly not nearly as plentiful as vets that recommend the crap they sell (ie Science Diet).  Which IMO is a horrible dog food.

If you research raw feeding you will find many of the articles and research done by vets.

I think vets are mostly concerned with the feeding of bone and the samonella issue.  But we can all see that samonella can be found in kibble and we all know kibble that has killed dogs.  If you study what is actually in kibble, taken out of kibble during the whole manufacturing process and then all the stuff you can't pronounce put back into kibble it would sicken you.  I'm not into my dogs eating road kill, dead rotting animals and all the parts.

With my intro into the raw feeding I did just what you are doing.  I fed kibble (Grain free "Now") and Natures Variety prepackaged raw.  It worked very well for me.  I would recommend you add more Omega 3 & 6 to the diet via wild salmon oil or something similar.

Due to the high cost of the prepackaged raw I now fed RAW only.  I belong to a co-op so I can get large volume, high quality organic, grass feed meats much less per lb then the prepackaged raw.  My dogs eat way better then me and I know exactly what they are eating.  What I don't do is feed chicken bones at all.  I will only feed ground fowl, but I let me dogs chew on raw meaty bones, knuckle bones (beef, venison and i have some Emu knuckles bones ordred). I do not feed rib bones.  Too old school I guess and those bones are sharp.

My vet is fine with me feeding raw, he just doesn't like me feeding bones.  He had to unimpact my old guy that wasn't digesting the bone and it impacted him.  Took a lot of work to clean him out (via cathater violation) and I'm lucky he didn't get perforated and that we didn't have to do surgery.  So he gets very little bone and every couple of weeks he gets a good healthy serving of tripe and organ to keep him cleaned out.

judy wilson's picture

becasue...they dont have a clue

my suggestion is to find a good holistic vet...most holistic vet are into raw feeding the reg vets make their money off kibble..and cant be bothered to do the research to help new owners feed raw.....they dont want the problems should some thing go wrong!!!!!!   their just lazy....be careful with raw and kibble always feed your kibble at nite as it takes longer to digest than raw.....look into honest kithen its really good,,,and its grain free and you can add in raw meats ect...their also a great group on face bood raw feeding friends.....just to learn and have fun......education before you start raw is very very important.....have fun with it is my motto

CathyandAudrey's picture

Because they have no knowledge of it

And they think you are too stupid to figure out how to feed your dog properly. They have been taught by dog food manufacturers about how very complicated and difficult canine nutrition is, and that you need complex scientific formulas to do it right.

Well, if we were trying to take inappropriate for carnivores waste from the human food industry and turn it into something a dog could live on, then yes it would be complicated. 

It is ABSURD and absolutely unacceptable in 20-freakin 12 for a medical professional to tell anyone that the BEST way to feed ANY SPECIES of animal is the most highly processed, devoid of moisture and nutrient, as far from the natural state and it is possible to get dried up food that can sit in a bag for years and not rot. 

Everyone knows by now that the BEST food for ANY creature is food as close to it's natural state as you can get. It's common knowledge that highly processed foods are the least nutritious and should NEVER make up the entire diet.

Why in the WORLD would dogs be the one and ONLY exception to that?!? It is crazy that any vet would STILL try to sell people that load of nonsense.

I am only feeding one dog. I do not buy in bulk. I don't have any available co-ops or any places to get large quantities of meat.

My dog only eats around 12 oz of food a day, or 22 pounds of meat a month.  It doesn't matter of I have 100 pounds stored or none stored at all, she still only eats 12 oz a day. Yes it's nice to have food in the freezer, but we have to shop for the humans anyways, it's NOT an outrageous big deal to add meat for Audrey to the cart too.

__________________

Cathy and Audrey